The debate about English playersâ first touch, distribution and composure under pressure is a long-running one being highlighted currently as Roy Hodgsonâs side labour to qualify for the World Cup.
Signs of real improvement, and a credible push for silverware, will occur only when St Georgeâs Park produces sufficient youth coaches and the academies develop psychologically tough as well as technically accomplished graduates.

This was the type of goodwill visit that wins so many friends. The locals were too polite to mention the slight irony of Englishmen teaching Brazilians skills.
âComing here you see they are technically very gifted,ââ said Walcott.
âWe had a stroll on the beach on Thursday and seeing some of the kids who were six or seven using their shoulders and everything to play beach volley. I canât even do that myself. It shows technically they have got it out here.â
Jermain Defoe agreed, adding: âI saw some girls doing it as well. It was unbelievable. You arenât surprised really because when you come to Brazil thatâs what you expect. The talent.
"Even here watching the kids finishing, the technique is unbelievable. I just said about the power in that girlâs shot; wow we should get her on free-kicks.â
As the players gathered at Bola Pra Frente, news filtered through of Rio Ferdinandâs tweets about English deficiencies.
âIn the last 10 years when have England played consistently well?ââ observed the Manchester United defender.
âA coaching strategy for our young teams/kids needs to be implemented to see change. In most PL teams retaining the ball is done best by foreign players in the team.... they are taught to pass to a man with a man on. So-called âGolden Generationâ obviously wasnât because we won nothing! Great players donât always make great teams.â
Ferdinandâs disparagement flowed in the wake of Gary Linekerâs criticism of âDark Agesâ England. âHeâs a legend, heâs a Spurs man,ââ said Defoe.
âI respect Gary Lineker as a forward and obviously being a Tottenham man, everyone has their opinion, thatâs life. If thatâs going to hurt you then youâre a weak person. As a group we stick together and try to win football matches.â
As for Ferdinand, Defoe said: âAgain no problem. Iâm not having a row with Rio. Heâs my mate and I love Rio. If he feels that way then he does.â
Defoe sought to introduce some balance into the argument. âSometimes when Iâm driving round the local area Iâll go over to the park and watch the kids play, they are still sharp,ââ said Defoe.
âBut itâs different over here. A lot of the kids drop out of school really early and maybe when they drop out they get the ball out and just play football.
"By doing that thatâs going to help you develop as a footballer. Thereâs a lot of talent over here but thereâs a lot of talent at home as well.â
There is talent but not in sufficient quantities as nurtured by more thoughtful countries like Spain, Germany, Argentina and Brazil.
âMy time in and around the squad has been fantastic, great moments great games and great team performances, sometimes it takes time,ââ said Defoe âbut I feel weâve got a good mix now with young players and senior players.
âWe had a conversation on the bus about the last World Cup and we were talking about the loss to Germany. We should have gone in 2-2 at half-time and I remember first 10-15 minutes of the second half and as a team we played some good stuff.
"In the last game against Brazil, the performance was amazing. We beat Spain at home. Qualify for the World Cup and see what happens at the World Cup, then weâll get judged then.ââ
Work is being done on youth development. âGermany did it about 10 years ago and spent about âŹ50âmillion on it,ââ said Sir Trevor Brooking, the FAâs director of football development, who was watching events at Bola Fra Prente.
âI was at a workshop last August when Joachim Löw was talking about it and I said to Roy, âthatâs where we need to be in 10 yearsâ time. We need to get 18, 19, 20-year-olds breaking into first teams of the Premier League.
âWe want the clubs focusing on making the 16-year-old English players better than they have been. We believe you need full-time coaches.
"At the moment there is an issue in that those full-time places are being offered at pretty low salaries, around ÂŁ15,000 to ÂŁ16,000 a year and they need to be recognised for the quality and getting ÂŁ40,000 to ÂŁ50,000.
"If you get two coaches in the 12-16 and two in the 5-11 you are talking ÂŁ160,000 to ÂŁ200,000 a year and in the scheme of things thatâs not asking too much to invest in quality coaches in those age groups so that the 16-year-olds are going to be much better than they are at the moment.â
Englandâs visit to the favela was a welcome sign that they are more prepared to step out of their five-star bubble, engaging with the local community, however fleetingly.
âItâs humbling coming to places like this and when you go away you realise how blessed you are,ââ said Defoe. âFor them it must be a dream meeting some of the England players and the manager.ââ
Source